Iced Coffee at a Job Interview: Let’s Focus on What Matters

News • By Richard Eib •

By Richard Eib | Jersey Hired

In 30 years of recruitment, I’ve learned that the most important question about a candidate is whether they can do the job.

Whether they arrive at their interview carrying an iced coffee tells us very little about the answer.

A recent viral debate has put that distinction in the spotlight. Recruiter Caitlin Wehniainen criticized candidates for bringing iced coffee to job interviews, arguing that a takeaway drink can make the meeting seem like another stop on a list of errands. The comments sparked a wider discussion about interview etiquette, generational expectations and professionalism. Read the coverage from Inc.

My view is straightforward: employers should give far more weight to a candidate’s skills, experience and ability to contribute than to the drink in their hand.

Is Bringing Iced Coffee to a Job Interview Unprofessional?

A coffee on its own is a poor measure of professionalism.

Professionalism shows up in how someone communicates, prepares, listens and treats others. It shows up when a candidate explains their experience honestly, asks thoughtful questions and demonstrates an understanding of the role.

Someone can arrive without a drink and be completely unprepared. Someone else can arrive holding an iced latte and give clear, relevant examples of how they would solve the problems your business faces.

We should be able to recognize the stronger candidate in that situation.

Of course, behavior matters. If someone repeatedly interrupts the conversation, spills a drink and leaves someone else to deal with it, or appears disengaged, that deserves attention. But the useful evidence is how they behave. Merely carrying a coffee doesn’t establish any of those things.

What Employers Should Look for in a Job Interview

An interview is valuable time for both sides. Hiring managers should use it to gather evidence that helps them make a sound decision.

These are the questions I would encourage employers to prioritize:

  • Does the candidate have the relevant skills? Ask them to explain how they have used those skills in situations similar to the work ahead.
  • Can they demonstrate results? Explore what they contributed, the challenges they faced and what happened as a result.
  • How do they solve problems? Give them a realistic scenario and listen to their reasoning.
  • Can they learn? Look for examples of adapting, accepting feedback or mastering something unfamiliar.
  • Do they communicate and work well with others? Ask for specific examples of collaboration and handling disagreement.

These questions take more effort than making a snap judgment about appearance or interview etiquette. They also give you much more useful information.

For New Jersey employers competing for capable people, overlooking a strong candidate because of an iced coffee is an unnecessary hiring mistake.

Interview Standards Should Have a Clear Connection to the Job

There are roles where presentation, hygiene, safety or formal client expectations are directly relevant. Employers are entitled to assess those requirements and explain them clearly.

But we should ask ourselves whether a particular expectation actually helps us evaluate someone’s suitability.

If drinks aren’t permitted in the interview area, tell candidates beforehand. If a role requires someone to navigate formal meetings, assess that skill with relevant questions or an exercise.

Unspoken preferences make weak selection criteria. A candidate shouldn’t have to guess a hiring manager’s personal feelings about takeaway cups.

A useful discipline is to decide what a good answer or strong performance looks like before the interview begins. Ask candidates a consistent set of core questions, then record evidence against the requirements of the role.

That keeps the conversation focused and makes it easier to explain why one person is better suited to the position.

Advice for Candidates: Should You Bring Coffee to an Interview?

My practical advice to job seekers is to finish your coffee beforehand where possible.

Interviewers have different expectations, and you can’t control every assumption they make. Keeping unnecessary distractions out of the meeting lets you put the attention on your experience and preparation.

Then focus on the things that deserve your energy: research the employer, understand the job, prepare examples of your achievements and bring questions that help you decide whether the opportunity is right for you.

You’re assessing the employer, too. The way an organization treats candidates can help you understand what working there might feel like.

Better Hiring Starts With Better Questions

After 30 years in recruitment, I believe we serve employers and candidates best when we stay focused on evidence.

An interview should help us understand what a person knows, what they have achieved and what they could contribute next. Small personal preferences shouldn’t crowd out those bigger questions.

At Jersey Hired, my message to New Jersey employers is simple: give candidates a fair opportunity to demonstrate their value.

The next person who can make a real difference to your business might walk into the interview carrying an iced coffee. Be ready to listen to what they have to say.